PAPA LUIGI ELMER CATERING

Italian Catering in Elmer, NJ

From office lunches and birthday parties to family celebrations and larger gatherings, bring Papa Luigi to the table.

Feed the Whole Crowd

Good catering doesn’t need to be complicated.

Papa Luigi offers a variety of easy-to-serve favorites for parties and events, including hot sandwich trays, subs, wraps, meatballs, sausage with peppers and onions, mac and cheese, garlic knots and more. We can help you put together an order that makes sense for your group instead of leaving you guessing how much food to buy.

Two different pizza slices on a wooden serving paddle

Full Service Italian Menu

Let Papa Luigi prepare the menu, or create your own choices from our large variety of authentic dishes.

Overhead view of linguine with clams and herbs

Appetizers

Chicken Fingers

50 pieces $49.99 100 pieces $89.99 Each $0.99

With Dijon mustard, BBQ or honey mustard dipping sauce.

Chicken Wings

50 pieces $49.99 100 pieces $89.99 Each $0.99

Hot, medium or BBQ.

Boneless Wings

100 pieces $64.99 Each $0.75

Hot, medium or BBQ.

Stromboli Bites

30 pieces $45.00

Steak, pepperoni or vegetable.

Mini Sausage or Pepperoni Rolls

30 pieces $35.00

Coated with Parmesan cheese.

Garlic Knots

50 pieces $15.00 100 pieces $25.00

Domestic Cheese

18-inch tray $85.00 16-inch tray $75.00

With pepperoni and red grapes. The 18-inch tray serves 40–50; the 16-inch tray serves 25–35.

Fresh Garden Vegetables and Dip

18-inch tray $75.00 16-inch tray $60.00

The 18-inch tray serves 40–50; the 16-inch tray serves 25–35.

Sandwich Trays

Assorted Hoagies Tray

12 pieces $34.99 24 pieces $69.99 Per sub $7.99

Italian, turkey, ham, tuna and Papa Sub, all with lettuce, tomato, olive oil, mayo, peppers and pickles. Tray subs are cut into quarters; individual subs are cut into thirds.

Assorted Wraps Tray

12 pieces $39.99 20 pieces $69.99 Per wrap $6.99

Ham and cheese, turkey, tuna, chicken Caesar, veggie, honey mustard chicken, Buffalo tenders, chicken BBQ and more choices. All cut in half.

Cheesesteak and Chicken Cheesesteak Tray

24 pieces $69.00 Per steak $8.99

Our award-winning cheesesteaks and chicken cheesesteaks, cut into quarters.

Cheesesteak Egg Roll Platter

20 pieces $49.99 40 pieces $89.99

2.5 oz. pieces. Sauce and dip available upon request.

Garden Salads

Half tray serves 10–15 • Medium tray serves 20–25 • Full tray serves 40–50

Add grilled chicken or tenders: Half $5.00 • Medium $10.00 • Full $15.00

Choice of dressing: French, creamy Italian, lite Italian, house, ranch, blue cheese, Caesar, honey mustard, Russian or raspberry vinaigrette.

Tossed Salad

Half $35.00 Medium $45.00 Full $55.00

A blend of romaine and iceberg lettuce, tossed with sweet peppers, cherry tomatoes and cucumbers, topped with homemade garlic croutons. Choice of dressing.

Classic Romaine Caesar Salad

Half $40.00 Medium $50.00 Full $75.00

Fresh chopped romaine lettuce topped with a blend of Italian cheeses, homemade garlic croutons, diced hard-cooked eggs and creamy Caesar dressing.

Fresh Spinach Salad

Half $45.00 Medium $55.00 Full $85.00

With feta cheese, candied walnuts and strawberries. Served with raspberry vinaigrette dressing.

Chef’s Salad

Half $45.00 Medium $55.00 Full $85.00

A blend of iceberg and romaine lettuce topped with rolled ham, turkey, salami and provolone cheese, finished with diced hard-cooked eggs. Served with choice of dressing.

Deli Salads & Cold Platters

Homemade Cole Slaw

Per lb. $3.49

Pasta Salad

Per lb. $4.99

Homemade Potato Salad

Per lb. $4.99

No eggs.

Tri-Color Tortellini Salad

Per lb. $5.99

Bruschetta

Per lb. $5.99

Diced tomatoes, red onions, garlic and basil.

Sweet or Hot Peppers

16 oz. $2.99

Mozzarella Caprese Tray

18-inch tray $79.99

Fresh sliced tomatoes, mozzarella di Buffalo, basil, roasted pepper and extra virgin olive oil. Serves 30.

Antipasta Tray

18-inch tray $85.95

Cured Italian meat and imported cheese. Serves 40–50.

Homemade Soups

Half gallon (64 oz.), serving approximately 8 people. Crackers and bread upon request.

Italian Wedding

$15.99

Shrimp Bisque

$19.50

Pasta Fagioli

$15.99

Cream of Potato

$15.99

Cream of Broccoli

$15.99

Chicken Tortellini

$15.99

Accompaniments

Half tray serves 10–15 • Medium tray serves 20–25 • Full tray serves 40–50

Roasted Red Peppers

Per lb. $12.00

In fresh garlic and extra virgin olive oil with Kalamata olives.

Roasted Italian Long Hots

Per lb. $12.00

In fresh extra virgin olive oil or marinara sauce.

Broccoli Rabe

Per lb. $15.00

Served warm or chilled.

Baked Mac and Cheese

Half $39.00 Medium $49.00 Full $59.99

Fresh String Beans and Potatoes

Half $40.00 Medium $50.00 Full $75.00

Mixed with garlic and olive oil.

Fresh String Beans

Half $35.00 Medium $45.00 Full $75.00

With garlic and olive oil or marinara sauce.

Steamed Fresh Broccoli and Cauliflower

Half $39.00 Medium $49.00 Full $75.00

With garlic and olive oil.

Steamed Fresh Broccoli

Half $39.00 Medium $49.00 Full $75.00

In a homemade cheese sauce.

Eggplant Fungettelle

Half $44.00 Medium $55.00 Full $75.00

Diced eggplant with marinara sauce and shaved Parmigiano-Reggiano.

Eggplant Rolletini

Half $34.95 Full $75.00

Lightly breaded, wrapped with ricotta cheese and sautéed spinach, topped with mozzarella.

Spinach

Half $40.00 Medium $50.00 Full $65.00

Sautéed in fresh garlic and olive oil.

Italian Vegetable Medley

Half $40.00 Medium $45.00 Full $60.00

A seasoned vegetable blend of carrots, broccoli, cauliflower and more.

Golden Whole Kernel Corn

Half $40.00 Medium $45.00 Full $60.00

Sweet whole kernel corn, lightly tossed in butter and seasoned to perfection.

Roasted Redskin Potatoes

Half $30.00 Medium $45.00 Full $85.00

Hand-cut redskin potatoes, seasoned with a special herb blend.

Mash Potatoes

Half $35.00 Medium $45.00 Full $85.00

Hand-smashed potatoes, seasoned lightly with salt, pepper, butter and a dash of a special herb blend.

Redskin Garlic Smashed Potatoes

Half $35.00 Medium $45.00 Full $85.00

Seasoned to perfection and smashed with love.

Meat Entrées

1 oz. Meatballs

Per lb. $8.99

In our homemade tomato sauce.

Hot Roast Beef

Per lb. $9.59

Thinly sliced beef served in our au jus gravy or, upon request, our mushroom onion gravy.

Top Round Roast Beef

Per lb. $12.99

Sliced a bit thicker, in brown gravy with sliced mushrooms. Sold in 5 lb. increments.

Whole Carved Prime Rib

$180.00

Certified Angus Beef. 15 lb. average.

Italian Roasted Porchetta

Per lb. $8.99

Perfectly seasoned roast porchetta served in pork au jus. Minimum 5 lbs.

Sausage, Peppers and Onions

Per lb. $10.99

Italian sausage smothered in peppers and onions, served with or without our homemade sauce. 1 lb. yields 5 sandwiches.

Chicken Parmesan

25 pieces $125.00 Each $5.00

Boneless chicken breast breaded in our special Italian bread crumbs, topped with our homemade sauce and smothered in mozzarella cheese. Approximately 5 oz. per piece.

Chicken Marsala

25 pieces $125.00 Each $5.00

Savory chicken breast and earthy mushrooms smothered in our famous Marsala wine sauce. It is simply divine! Approximately 5 oz. per piece.

Chicken Scallopini

25 pieces $125.00 Each $5.00

Sliced chicken breast served with fresh-cut peppers, onions, mushrooms and olive oil, all tossed in our red sauce. Approximately 5 oz. per piece.

Chicken Piccante

25 pieces $125.00 Each $5.00

With fresh shiitake mushrooms. Approximately 5 oz. per piece.

Chicken Bruschetta

25 pieces $125.00 Each $5.00

Grilled chicken breast topped with our homemade bruschetta and provolone cheese. Approximately 5 oz. per piece.

Penne Pasta

Half tray serves 10–15 • Medium tray serves 20–25 • Full tray serves 40–50

Alla Vodka

Half $45.00 Medium $59.95 Full $99.99

Blush vodka sauce with cured Parma prosciutto and Parmigiano-Reggiano.

Grilled Chicken and Broccoli

Half $45.00 Medium $55.99 Full $99.99

Sautéed in a creamy Alfredo sauce.

Pasta Primavera

Half $40.00 Medium $49.99 Full $89.99

Zucchini, mushrooms, roasted peppers and eggplant in a light sauce or creamy sauce.

Chicken and Roasted Peppers

Half $40.00 Medium $49.99 Full $99.99

In a garlic white wine sauce.

Chicken and Roasted Peppers with Asparagus

Half $45.00 Medium $55.00 Full $125.00

In a brandy cream sauce.

Luigi’s Pasta Favorites

Half tray serves 10–15 • Medium tray serves 20–25 • Full tray serves 40–50

Rigatoni, Penne or Spaghetti

Half $35.99 Medium $45.00 Full $70.00

With fresh pomodoro sauce.

Baked Ziti

Half $45.00 Medium $55.00 Full $89.99

With ricotta, mozzarella and fresh basil.

Pasta Meat Sauce

Half $45.00 Medium $49.99 Full $99.99

Baked Gnocchi

Half $45.00 Medium $49.99 Full $89.99

Traditional cheese with choice of red, blush, Alfredo or pomodoro sauce.

Stuffed Shells

25 pieces $49.99 35 pieces $64.99 50 pieces $85.00

With fresh pomodoro sauce.

Ricotta Cheese Ravioli

24 pieces $24.99 50 pieces $39.99 96 pieces $75.00

Round, with our Alfredo, blush or pomodoro sauce.

Lobster Ravioli

24 pieces $65.00 50 pieces $120.00

With a creamy blush sauce.

Fresh Baked Lasagna

Cheese $69.95 Vegetable $79.95 Meat $89.95

Your choice of cheese, vegetable or meat lasagna. Full tray only.

Eggplant Parmigiana Lasagna

Full tray $89.99

Lightly battered eggplant, fried and layered with mozzarella and ricotta, topped with a fresh plum tomato sauce. Full tray only.

Tortellini Alfredo

Half $40.00 Medium $49.00 Full $89.00

With Parmigiano Reggiano cheese.

Tortellini Alla Papa

Half $45.00 Medium $59.99 Full $99.99

Prosciutto, peas and onions in a creamy Alfredo sauce.

Breads & Rolls

Large Italian Loaf

Each $4.99

Kaiser Rolls

Per dozen $6.99

Dinner Rolls

Per dozen $5.99

Garlic Stix (8-inch)

Per dozen $8.99